Rumour has it that the VHF
and UHF 625 line 50 field PAL transmissions will end in Australia in a
few years. That is, if you believe rumours. It remains to be seen if they
really do get turned off. Put simply, the demand for digital TV isn't there.
Australia is fortunate in using the best TV system in the world. 625 lines
and chroma phase error immunity with the PAL system gives us a considerable
advantage over certain other countries. In fact, with a good aerial, the
digital picture is no better than its analog equivalent. So why is big
business pushing the government to implement it?
The main reason from media
organisations is that six channels of digital can be put in the same bandwidth
of one analog channel. So, six times as much advertising! What really happens
is there's six times as much crap; there's only a finite amount of television
programming that can be made.
The other main reason comes
from electronics manufacturers. What a good way to force everyone to buy
new TV sets or digital boxes! All that income for the greedy manufacturers.
In reality, people have to buy things they don't and didn't need, and China
uses up the world's resources making all this new stuff, furthering environmental
damage.
Having said that, there
is one useful feature of digital TV. In areas where even the best aerial
won't get rid of the ghosts, digital TV will. (At this point I need to
mention that anti ghost systems were developed for analog TV during the
1970's & 80's but consumers weren't interested).
Also in areas where the
signal is not strong enough to provide a snow free picture, the digital
system will...but up to a point. Below a certain signal level, the digital
signal is lost, leaving the viewer with nothing, or a blocky jumpy picture
at best, with defective sound. An analog picture would still exist at this
level.
Conventional signal strength
meters do not work with digital signals as they resemble a 7MHz block of
noise. A spectrum analyser is the best way to see what's going on with
the aerial system.
It surprises me that some
people are worried their monochrome VHF TV set won't be useable if the
shutdown occurs. There is no need for alarm. A television made in 1956
works on the same 625 line 50 field negative modulation, 5.5MHz FM sound
transmissions we use today. The only difference is that in 1974 the chroma
subcarrier was switched on at the TV stations (colour had been transmitted
experimentally since the late 1960's but as the government didn't want
people importing colour sets to view these transmissions, the colour subcarrier
was removed prior to transmission).
So, just like with a modern
colour set, the method of using your antique for digital is the same. Digital
boxes are getting to under $40 now. One model I like is the DVX555 sold
by Strathfield Car Radio. This box allows you to install a hard disc which
you can record TV on. It costs $69 but you have to supply your own hard
disc. Any capacity can be used; the box automatically formats. Obviously
the larger the hard disc, the more it can record. There's plenty of info
on the internet on this box if you want to search.
An interesting feature of
the DVX555 is that you can select NTSC output in the setup menu. This means
that you can effectively use an American TV set to watch the Australian
digital TV channels, in colour, without any modifications. Programs can
also be recorded on an NTSC VCR or fed into an NTSC only video capture
card etc. If you like collecting foreign TV sets this is a very useful
feature. I discuss it further here.
The DVX555 doing the channel scan at setup. Set is
a 1957 Kriesler 79-1 chassis, Model 121-1.
There's a slight problem
now; most of these boxes have only baseband audio and video out, and a
few have UHF output. Not very useful on a VHF TV with no AV inputs. What
to do? Where the box has only AV outputs:
1) Feed the baseband inputs
into a VCR that outputs on a VHF channel.
2)Get a VHF modulator and
feed the box into that.
Where the box also has UHF
output, you can:
1)Feed the UHF into a VCR
that outputs on a VHF channel.
2)Use a UHF to VHF converter.
A
word on VHF channels:
It is important to know
that the VHF channels of 1956 are not the same as the VHF channels of now.
In 1961, the number of channels was increased from 10 to 13. The government
hadn't anticipated the demand for TV in australia.
Briefly, the old channels
1,4, and 5 were changed in frequency, and new channels 0, 5A, and 11 were
added. For commercial interests, the existing channels operating at the
time 2,7,9 in the mainland capitals, and 2 and 6 in Hobart, Tasmania did
not have their channel number changed. This is why we have channel O and
5A.
The channels that did not
change are: 2,3,6,7,8,9,10 (10 did but only by 1Mc/s which is insignificant
and well within the range of the fine tuning control). As Australian VCR's
with VHF output transmit on either 0/1 or 3/4, you need a 3/4 model for
a pre 1961 TV set. The UHF converters once sold by Tandy also output on
3 or 4.
You can use a 0/1 model
if you wish...
The old channel 1 is about
4Mc/s higher than channel 0, so providing there's enough adjustment in
the local oscillator you can tune down to channel 0. You should really
retune the RF circuit but in practice just the local oscillator is enough.
I was doing this since the
days of SBS being on channel 0 in Sydney and had good results.
You can also tune up to
the present channel 1, but this usually requires a greater range of adjustment.
With my Ekco
TX287 I had to add a few pF across the oscillator coil in the tuner
to get its channel 1 down to channel 0. Why didn't I use channel 3? Because
this biscuit was not fitted in the tuner.
One handy feature is the program guide (this can be
done with the analog system as per Teletext)
To keep with the period theme, you can get valve UHF converters off the US eBay. Their channel 6 is close enough to our channel 3.
The other option of course is to simply provide AV inputs on your TV. I'm not recommending this as it means doing mods (i.e.. butchery). The audio level from a digital box is compatible with the typical triode pentode audio stage and can be fed into the set's volume control via a capacitor (something like .1uF). The unterminated video output of the box is 2Vp-p which will drive a video output pentode. Terminating it in the correct 75 ohms will reduce the level and perhaps provide insufficient contrast. In practice with short leads the correct termination isn't important. A potential problem is with sets that have their contrast control as part of the AGC system; this will not work properly with direct video input. I won't go into this any further, but merely mention it as being possible.
Aerials
Outdoor
TV aerials and even reception of TV signals off air is almost a thing of
the past in many parts of the world due to the penetration of cable systems,
and in arrogant stuck up housing estates where they don't allow outdoor
aerials. Fortunately, in Australia off air reception rules, and most houses
have outdoor TV aerials. Cable TV has been in Australia since around 1996
and due to population density (low..thankfully), and also some obstructive
local councils, cabling was installed only in parts of the larger capital
cities and towns.
Everywhere
else gets pay TV from Satellite. In the past, MMDS was also used but was
closed down around 2001. The satellite pay channels do not carry the free
channels due to the three time zones, local news, and advertising requirements,
so terrestrial VHF and UHF reception is still required.
Don't
automatically be conned into needing a "digital" aerial or "digital" whatever.
The digital transmissions are in the same VHF and UHF bands used for years.
I
live about 80km from Gore Hill and about 90km from Knight's Hill. There
are three TV aerials feeding my system. There's a circa 1965 Channel Master
636 Valiant for the Gore Hill VHF channels 2,7,9,and 10. Above this is
a 91 element UHF aerial, a clone of the Fuba XC391. This receives Gore
Hill UHF channels 28 and 31. A third 91 element UHF aerial receives the
Knight's Hill channels, Prime, WIN, Capital, ABC, and SBS.
All
three aerials are connected to my distribution system under the house by
300 ohm ribbon. This has much lower loss than coaxial cable, especially
on UHF. The Gore Hill and Knight's Hill UHF signals are combined by a Johanssen
band 4/5 diplexer and then amplified by 28dB. The amplified UHF signals
then feed into a VHF/UHF diplexer which also accepts the VHF signal which
has 15dB of amplification. The combined signal then passes into a six way
splitter for distribution around the house and garage via RG59 coaxial
cable.
Aerials for Gore Hill (Sydney) reception. On top is
the 91 element UHF aerial connected by slotted 300 ohm ribbon. Under is
the Channel Master 636 from the mid 1960's. This aerial was rescued from
a building site where it had been trampled on. There's even a toothbrush
handle used to splint the low band dipole!
While
this system works well on the analog system, there is a slight problem
with ABC on digital. I noticed dropouts on ABC1 and ABC2 while other channels
were good. These channels are transmitted on Ch 12. Connecting the VHF
aerial to a spectrum analyser showed what the problem was. There's a severe
roll off at the top end of the VHF band with the old Channel Master aerial.
The Ch 12 signal is not only much attenuated but you can actually see the
frequency response sloping off! I shouldn't be too surprised given the
distance I am from the transmitter and the fact that Yagi aerials do not
have an even frequency response like log periodics do. The other factor
is the aerial simply wasn't designed for reception of Ch 12. In fact it
may be so old as not to have even been designed for Ch 10 reception. Remember
that until 1965 there was only Ch's 2, 7, and 9 operating in the larger
capital cities.
In
my situation the way out of the problem is simple. When I want the ABC
channels on digital, I simply use the Knight's Hill signal. That way I
can keep using my antique VHF aerial.
For Knight's Hill (Wollongong) reception, this 91
element UHF aerial is used. It's the same model as the one for Gore Hill,
which can be seen to the left.
For
everyone else, if you have problems with the ABC, and possibly Ch 10, digital
channels and you're using a VHF Yagi, you might need to replace it. The
only new VHF aerials I recommend are those made by Matchmaster. These are
the only ones I will install for other people. Why? Most other aerials
are very flimsy and are full of plastic insulators which deteriorate in
the weather and their numerous rivetted connections are unreliable. Additionally,
their anti ghosting properties are absolutely useless. The AntSig aerials
sold by Dick Smith, Bunnings and other discount type stores are amongst
the worst. So are those log periodics made by Hills.(Telray and Pathfinder
series). (Slight exception given to the EFC2/3/4 which are reasonable for
anti ghosting). I'm not too fond of the Hills UHF aerials either
(like the TC18 etc.) these are a copy of the Antiference designs from the
UK. The problem is they don't have a balun and have coaxial cable connected
straight to the folded dipole. Unbalancing the dipole like this changes
the directional characteristics of the aerial.
In
my opinion, the best VHF aerial ever made was the Channel Master 3112.
What this does in ghost prone areas is like magic. Unfortunately this has
not been made for many years but luckily I do have a couple of surviving
examples in good condition.
Digital Channel 44. This has what are termed "narrowcasting"
channels. Digital TV wasn't even dreamed of when this set was made but
as you can see it performs perfectly with the new signals.
Interference
from digital signals
It
should also be mentioned that the present transmissions are causing interference
to some sets. This is because the digital signals are adjacent to VHF channels
in use. Does your set suffer from hiss in the sound on Channel 7 or 9?
If so, that's because Ch 7 digital is on VHF channel 6, and Ch 9 is broadcasting
its digital signal on channel 8.
This
is particularly bad on my 5 inch 5BP1 TV set as I did not incorporate
any adjacent channel rejection traps when I built its IF strip.
UHF
is just as problematic. Here in the Blue Mountains where I receive snow
free the Gore Hill and Knight's Hill transmitters, and numerous weaker
low power repeaters, it is impossible to find a clear UHF channel to tune
in the output of a VCR, satellite receiver, or digital box. So bad is the
situation, I have an RF switch box to disconnect the TV aerial system when
viewing from these devices. It seems there's either a repeater, digital
channel, or an intermodulation product of same right across the UHF band.
It would be nice if these devices had VHF outputs...and while we're at
it, how about RF outputs (preferably VHF) on DVD players as well?
The
obvious way to solve the interference is to make filters or traps. I did
experiment some years ago with quarter and half wavelengths of 300 ohm
ribbon for making a diplexer, and I'd say there's possibilities here.
email me: cablehack at yahoo dot com