I had a typical Catholic upbringing that formed the foundation
of religious belief into my early 20's. I won't recount the
details of my childhood, or the extent of my indoctrination,
but let's just say that I would independently study the bible
and seriously considered furthering my life in a religious way
(either as a priest or brother).
What woke me up most
was a book I read that highlighted the psychological dimension
to religious belief; also at the time I was attending university
and coming into contact with many people for whom religious
belief was at most a curiosity but more likely an irrelevance.
My sheltered school life had only exposed me to like-minded
individuals and now I had to think. I don't recall the exact
details in the book but it poked a few major holes in the christianity
argument that were just not reconcilable for me:
- SUFFERING
- the population of the Earth is roughly 6 billion - India/China
are nearly half of that total and are predominately non-christian
(not to mention other countries in Eastern Europe and south
East Asia which ar non-christian) - I don't know what proportion
of the world is Catholic (or even Christian) but to be overly
generous and let's say half. So what the Cathloics would have
you beleive is that a loving God created 3 billion people knowing
that they would spend an ETERNITY suffering - an ETERNITY!!
That makes '25 to life' look pretty tame!! What would be their
crime anyway? - that they didn't beleive in him? and didn't
worship him? Is He that insecure?? Wouldn't He be big enough
not to need to create people and then demand that they worship
Him on threat of ETERNAL damnation? This line of criticism was
really the killer for me - I can't get past a pointlessly cruel,
insecure, petty GOD - 3 billion real people!! and as that's
just the current generation!! not future or
- GOOD/EVIL
BALANCE - the theme of the bible is that the good will triumph
in the end (even if that is in the next life). Nice sentiment
which falls away if there is no after life!! Maybe some 'evil'
people don't get their just desserts; the pimps and drug dealers
may just be making huge amounts of money, living the high life
and having a good time!! No downside. Realising that there is
no guaranteed equilibrium is very confronting for a Catholic.
- Fear OF MORTALITY - since humans have becoe
self - aware they have struggled with motality; the current
relgions are just a longstanding history of humans trying to
comes to terms with death.-
- MIXED MESSAGES
- the problem confronting many is that the religion contains
many 'warm and fuzzy' sentiments - "love thy neighbour"
-that are mixed with very destructive ideas - self worthlessness,
sinfulness, weakness, sinfulness of sexual desire outside marriage
etc - as well as being bigotted towards groups such as homosexuals
(another group damned for ETERNITY). This mixing of ideas keeps
people in.
When I was confronting the lie that
is the Catholic religion it was very confronting and painful
- and I think only those going form ultra relgious to atheist
would know the pain associated withi this transition. What it
now most represents for me is wasted time and opportunties -
people I could have been closer to but wasn't because of religion.
I am now free from that belief system.
What a waste -
it is good that society is moving towards a more tolerant position
and secular position.
Details